Why Cayman Islands vs BVI
A perspective on jurisdictional superiority for private client structuring
By Peter Goddard, Founder, IMG Trust Company
For high-value international clients, the choice of offshore jurisdiction matters – especially in an era of increased transparency, global regulatory scrutiny, and a heightened focus on governance. While BVI has historically been a go-to jurisdiction, Cayman now clearly leads in multiple areas that are critical to private client lawyers and dispute specialists.
Legal Infrastructure and Judiciary
- Cayman’s judiciary is widely regarded as one of the strongest offshore, with a dedicated Financial Services Division of the Grand Court and access to the UK Privy Council as final appellate court.
- Judges are resident, full-time, and highly experienced in trust, insolvency, and cross-border commercial disputes – providing consistency, predictability, and confidence to clients and advisors.
- BVI, in contrast, has faced criticism for judicial delays, limited court resources, and an over-reliance on visiting judges.
“Cayman now clearly leads in multiple areas that are critical to private client lawyers and dispute specialists.”
Regulatory Environment
- Cayman is not on the EU blacklist or grey list as of 2025, reflecting its high level of cooperation and compliance with international standards.
- BVI remains on the EU grey list, raising concerns for banks, intermediaries, and institutional trustees regarding increased scrutiny and potential reputational risk.
Service Provider Quality
- Cayman offers depth and breadth of professional services, including top-tier law firms, trustees, accountants, and fiduciary providers, with well-regulated independent directors and trust companies.
- BVI’s smaller professional base limits availability of sophisticated service providers, particularly in complex private wealth and dispute scenarios.
Court Efficiency & Dispute Resolution
- Cayman’s trust industry benefits from a streamlined process for court approvals, e.g., trustee blessings, variation of trusts, and directions.
- Court timelines are efficient and predictable, supporting pre-emptive structuring and conflict resolution.
- BVI continues to face delays and inconsistencies in case progression, particularly problematic in urgent or contentious matters.
Privacy & Confidentiality
- Both jurisdictions comply with international transparency standards, but Cayman has resisted public registers, maintaining a controlled, access-based system in line with global obligations.
- BVI has moved ahead with public beneficial ownership registers, creating client privacy concerns, particularly among UHNW families and private offices.
Cayman is the jurisdiction of choice
Cayman offers legal certainty, efficient courts, high-quality professionals and judges, strong regulatory compliance, and a client-friendly balance of transparency and privacy. For lawyers advising international families and trustees, Cayman provides the legal and reputational safeguards your clients need.
View Peter’s Leaders List profile here.
Subscribe to the Citywealth Weekly Newsletter to learn more about Private Wealth Management.
Read more:
Insurance Can Be Used to Complement a Trust Strategy | Citywealth News
Digital Assets and PPLI Explained | Citywealth News
Private Placement Life Insurance | Citywealth News
The Hari Singapore to Open in 2027
Harilela Hotels has set its sights on Singapore as the third home for its acclaimed hotel brand The Hari, complementing the existing properties in London and Hong Kong.
Wimbledon Screen Returns to St Katharine Docks Bigger, Better, and Ready to Ace Wimbledon 2026
St. Katharine Docks returns with an upgraded outdoor screen for the Championships – now on Marble Quay with room for everyone!